In Arizona, school letter grades come out in the fall. I found out my school earned an A grade in October 2018, at a time when I was completely absorbed in my state’s election. I’m an Arizona teacher and I was working hard to defeat Proposition 305 (a school voucher expansion) and get pro-education candidates elected to our state legislature.
I was excited for the A rating, but didn’t really have time to reflect on it. The election ended, holidays began and despite the school wide celebration, social media declarations, and the new banner flying in front of my school, I never did take a moment to think about the A rating and what it meant.
Fast forward one year and we are about to find out if we maintained our A label. Letter grades should be released to the public in early November.
For the past year, my school has been doggedly focused on keeping our A status. We have talked about reducing our minimally proficient students and increasing our highly proficient students. We brainstormed ways to reclassify our English Language Learners. We’ve asked ourselves how to increase the rigor for our high achievers so they still show growth on AzMerit. How can we help our special education students increase their pass rate on the test?
You see, in Arizona the way a school earns its letter grade is largely decided by the AzMerit assessment. This one test, in one moment of time, determines the label our schools are given.
We are feeling fairly confident. Although we haven’t yet received our letter grade, we have seen our data. Based on our analysis of the numbers, we predict we will maintain our A label.
My leadership team is excited and proud with some relief mixed in. Being an A school is a big deal in our state; local news outlets, social media, state politicians, and district administration never let us forget it. To really drive the point home, our governor implemented results based funding in 2017, connecting extra money to our letter grades.
As thrilled as I may be to celebrate the success and hard work of our students and staff, my excitement is tempered by my deeply held belief that there are better ways to evaluate schools.
Is our current system in Arizona the best way to measure school success? As much as politicians like to assert that the labeling system is well rounded and measures more than just test results, I find that to be untrue.
Of the 100 points available to K-8 schools to earn toward their letter grade, the vast majority is directly connected to AzMerit. Proficiency on AzMerit accounts for 30 points while growth on the test accounts for 50 points.
A category called Acceleration Readiness can potentially earn schools 10 points. This category has many subcategories worth a few points each, most of which are also based on AzMerit. A few categories that are not reliant on AzMerit are chronic absenteeism and special education inclusion, each worth 2 points.Growth shown by English Language Learners is worth 10 points. While it is not dependent entirely upon AzMerit, it is dependent upon another one time test, AZELLA.
When all is said and done, more than 90% of the points available to a K-8 school come from a high stakes test, with AzMerit representing more than 80%.
There are 180 school days in a year. One hundred eighty days of learning, successes, frustrations, and growth happening within the walls of each and every school. Reducing the significance of that work down to one test doesn’t seem like the best way to measure a school’s accomplishments.
There are other factors that lead to student success besides standardized tests. In no particular order, I would love to see some of the following considered:
- Student culture
- Number of arts and music classes offered
- Teacher turnover rate
- Foreign language as an opportunity
- Number of counselors
- Teacher working conditions
- Student leadership opportunities
- Family engagement
This is not an all-inclusive list, just a sampling of ways we can assess a school’s value beyond a standardized test. I believe our priorities are made visible by what we choose to inspect. When our state only inspects the high stakes test results, it diminishes the value of student and teacher work down to a single moment in time.
This isn’t a radical idea. A few states are already looking for ways to evaluate school effectiveness using measures other than standardized tests. Education professionals know there are better ways to measure a school’s impact on student achievement. Hopefully, those in decision-making positions will begin to see the value in looking beyond the confines of a high stakes test.
Until then, I’ll celebrate all the hard work and dedication that happens in my building. Not just on the day we receive our letter grade, but every day. Because real growth is happening each and every day on my campus and it deserves to be celebrated.
What ideas do you have for measuring the effectiveness of a school?